"Pyar Ke Sadqay" is the story of Abdullah (Bilal Abbas) and Mahjabeen (Yumna Zaidi), who are social misfits. Mahjabeen's character is that of an ingénue. Mahjabeen is a naïve, quirky, clumsy, carefree, overtalkative, and mischievous young woman who has failed the tenth-grade multiple times.